Dive Brief:
- HR professionals at organizations with a deliberate approach to diversity and inclusion work were more likely than those at “passive or avoidant” organizations to report meeting or exceeding retention, innovation, productivity and public reputation goals, according to a SHRM study released Tuesday.
- The study found HR pros rated open-door policies, flexible work arrangements and employee recognition as the most effective inclusion approaches. Success was best achieved through employee involvement (58%), buy-in (50%) and visible leadership support (45%), survey respondents told SHRM.
- SHRM’s study provides valuable insight into the effects of organizations’ attempts to alter or dump D&I programs over the past couple years. Those that maintained their commitment by “adapting programs while keeping values consistent” saw the most benefit, SHRM found.
Dive Insight:
SHRM used a 5-point scale, in which a 3 indicated meeting the goal, to gauge the relationship between I&D and revenue goals. It found that organizations with “very stable” or “mostly stable” I&D approaches reported higher revenue goal achievements (3.17 and 3.11, respectively) compared with those that “unstable” approaches (2.86). “Engagement followed the same pattern,” SHRM found.
Perhaps unsurprisingly, SHRM found that effectiveness was tied to employees’ sense that the work was driven by real dedication and interest in their participation. HR professionals who described their organization’s commitment to I&D work as “authentic,” as opposed to “performative,” were much more likely to say employees felt comfortable raising inclusion concerns.
The survey also found that changing political tides were most responsible for organizations dropping a formal I&D strategy. Executive orders on I&D drove more than half of organizations to drop their programs (52%) with “changes in the political environment” close behind (48%). Roughly one-third of HR pros (32%) pointed to changes in legal or regulatory requirements.
Internal factors played a smaller role in organizational abandonment of I&D, most notably restructuring or leadership turnover (25%), reduced budgets (19%) and lack of leadership support (18%).
SHRM surveyed 1,720 HR professionals via the SHRM Voice of Work Research Panel from July 28 to Aug. 10. It presented the findings on Tuesday in association with Blueprint for I&D, part of its All Things Work event in Nashville, Tennessee.
SHRM’s findings are notable in that employers do not necessarily have to maintain their approach without any changes to benefits, so long as they maintain the underlying commitment to building an inclusive culture.
Attorneys have cautioned employers to drop certain legally questionable methods of achieving D&I, like quotas or goals related to hiring, promotions and other employment actions. But practical methods of achieving inclusion, like the flexible work arrangements and recognition actions that HR pros reported to SHRM, can move organizations toward a more diverse and inclusive workplace — and consequently one that is more engaged and better-performing — without introducing similar legal risks.
“A true test of inclusion strategy is what employees can count on when conditions change,” Carolynn Johnson, president of the SHRM Center for Inclusion & Diversity, said in a statement Monday. “Leaders can adapt how they do the work and still be clear about the commitment. Tell employees what’s changing and why, give them a say in how changes are made and hold managers accountable for following through.”