Dive Brief:
- Eight former SpaceX employees need not arbitrate a claim they were fired for reporting sexual harassment, a divided 9th Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals held Nov. 10. SpaceX founder Elon Musk allegedly normalized and encouraged this conduct by posting sexually explicit comments on Twitter (now X), according to the plaintiffs.
- Per the ruling in Holland-Thielen v. SpaceX, the Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act applied to their claim because it allows individuals alleging a “sexual harassment dispute” to pursue the case in court, notwithstanding an arbitration agreement, the 9th Circuit held 2-1.
- The ruling follows other court decisions finding that the EFAA covers a broad swath of allegations involving sexual harassment, sexual assault or related conduct. Here, contrary to SpaceX’s argument, to avoid arbitration, the plaintiffs did not have to meet the stricter pleading standard of a federal sexual harassment lawsuit, such as by adequately alleging Musk’s social media posts were sufficiently severe or pervasive to create a sexually hostile work environment, the judges explained.
Dive Insight:
Congress passed the EFAA in 2021 in response to reports of pervasive sexual misconduct at various companies, some of which tried to hide the misconduct by requiring victims to resolve their claims in confidential arbitration through agreements protected by the Federal Arbitration Act, the two majority judges pointed out.
The EFAA amended the FAA to prevent plaintiffs who assert a “sexual harassment dispute” and claims related to the dispute from being compelled to arbitrate the claims, the judges said.
The SpaceX plaintiffs alleged that while they worked at the company, sexual banter, sexual harassment and gender discrimination were commonplace, according to the court. They also alleged that Musk promoted this conduct through Twitter posts, drawing employees to the posts by using Twitter to report company news and interspersing the news with sexually explicit comments as well as comments that demeaned women and LGBTQ individuals.
According to the plaintiffs, Musk’s posts were widely shared among SpaceX employees such that they “permeated” the workplace, the 9th Circuit said.
In a letter to management, the plaintiffs raised concerns about their work environment, focusing on Musk’s posts, which they asserted constituted sexual harassment. They also circulated the letter among their colleagues.
SpaceX fired the plaintiffs allegedly after it identified them as the employees who wrote, sent and circulated the letter. They sued in California court alleging state law violations. SpaceX removed the case to federal district court and asked the court to compel the plaintiffs to arbitrate their claims based on agreements it alleged they signed.
The district court denied the motion, and the 9th Circuit affirmed.
In August, in another 2-1 ruling, the 9th Circuit held that the EFAA permits plaintiffs to avoid arbitrating sex-based harassment claims even if a plaintiff first discovers during an arbitration proceeding that alleged misconduct was of a sexual nature.
Last year, a federal district court found that a former worker who claimed she had been a victim of domestic violence and was fired after requesting a reasonable accommodation for her safety could sue the employer for sex discrimination. The judge found she was exempt from arbitration under the EFAA because her claim involved a sexual assault, even though the assault wasn’t caused or enabled by the employer. The parties settled the claim in September.